BFR Explorer
Backflash rate by the CIGRE method
BFR Explorer calculates the backflash rate of a shielded overhead line by the CIGRE method, as presented in Hileman (1999), chapter 10, and implemented in Hileman's program BFR99. It takes the tower geometry, the insulation strength and the footing resistance along the line, and shows every formula and intermediate quantity behind the result. Shielding failures are not calculated.
Preparing the calculation engine (Python in the browser; about 10 MB is downloaded the first time).
What is calculated
For each grounding section this tool finds the critical current Ic. Ic is the smallest stroke current for which the surge voltage across the insulators, added to the power-frequency voltage, reaches the insulation strength CFONS. The surge includes the tower surge impedance and travel time, the footing resistance with soil ionisation, reflections from the adjacent towers and the coupling to the phase conductor. Front time and footing resistance are solved iteratively.
The backflash rate, in flashovers per 100 km per year, is then BFR = 0.6 · NL · P(I ≥ Ic). NL is the number of flashes to the line per 100 km per year. P(I ≥ Ic) is the probability that the stroke current is at least Ic, from the CIGRE log-normal stroke-current distribution (eq. 10.11 of the book). Sections are weighted by their share of the line length.
Basis and verification
The book is A. R. Hileman, Insulation Coordination for Power Systems (1999). The calculation was recovered from the BFR99 executable itself and rebuilt formula by formula; each function in the code cites its book equation and the BFR99 routine it comes from.
This tool was validated against:
- the unmodified BFR99 program, on its built-in example, its ground-rod and counterpoise calculators, the book's examples and randomly generated lines covering its methods and options;
- the worked examples and tables of the book's chapter 10 and Appendix 4.
Agreement with BFR99 is within the rounding of its single-precision arithmetic. Where BFR99 and the book disagree, the textbook examples show both values and, where it is known, the reason. Defects found in BFR99 are reproduced by default, so results stay comparable with the program; corrections are options marked not BFR99. One model, LPM Detail, stops in BFR99: it is rebuilt from the program's unused routines and checked against the book only.
Layout
Left panel · inputs
- Case
- New case, textbook examples, BFR99 input files.
- Line
- Tower and shield wires, span, ground flash density, altitude.
- Options
- Insulation-strength model, CIGRE simplified method, corona, power-frequency voltage and time lag.
- Phase conductor
- CFO, height and coupling factor of the phase whose insulation is checked.
- Phases
- Coupling factor, height, CFO and angle of each phase, shown instead of Phase conductor when all phases are used.
- Grounding sections
- Footing resistance and soil along the line.
Right panel · results, by tab
- Overview
- Line BFR, contribution of each section, stroke-current distribution.
- Line
- Cross-section to scale, Zg and C computed from the geometry and compared with the inputs, span reflections.
- Section
- One section in detail: insulator voltage, iterations, convergence.
- Studies
- BFR against footing resistance, sensitivity, insulation-strength models.
- Calculation sheet
- Every formula with its numbers, printable.
The header shows the line BFR and the calculation status. Guide reopens this window.
New case
Choose a tower. Its geometry, Zg, Zt, coupling factor, CFO and KPF come from the source shown. The rest of the line takes starting values, listed on the Overview tab; edit them in the left panel.
Textbook examples
The list holds Hileman's chapter 10 and Appendix 4 examples, built from the inputs the book states, and BFR99's built-in 115 kV line. The book's examples open on the Overview tab with the book's published value, BFR99's result where BFR99 was run, this tool's result and the differences in %.